Historical Representation

Many accounts exist of the heroic efforts and admirable sacrifices made by the Northern abolitionists who assisted those seeking freedom from bondage, and no one doubts the significance of their contributions within the Underground Railroad movement.  What has been brought into question by many historians, and where much historical revision is yet to be accomplished, is a more substantial inclusion of African Americans into their own history.  Their struggle for freedom did not happen passively, and did not begin with the abolitionist movement, but was an act of resistance from the very beginning. 
            Beyond the few personal narratives by slaves who gave accounts of their freedom from bondage, little is known about the early history of resistance and efforts to escape.  This lack of early documentation has led to a profound misrepresentation in the historical record, which has mistakenly presented the view that African Americans had a primarily passive role in their own emancipation.  Although attempts are being made to amend this gap in history, there is still much work to be accomplished in telling the entire story.  Jacqueline Tobin and Raymond G. Dobard, in Hidden in Plain View, describe some of the compelling methods of African Americans resistance in their detailed analysis of the use of quilts with secret coding patterns.  The authors also relate how the story of the Underground Railroad is also like a pattern to be deciphered:
The story of the Underground Railroad is a part of the much larger story of the personal and cultural survival of these proud African people, brought to America against their will.  It is a story of that spans the Atlantic, linking forever the peoples of Africa and America.  It is a story of places, North and South.  It is a story of secrets, involving routes and language, codes and music.  It is in the end, a story of triumph and freedom, brought at great price by individuals, cultures, and countries (54).
In order to decipher, or “decode” a portion of this story, I found it necessary to interview an individual whose knowledge and understanding might assist us in apprehending not only the historical significance of the Underground Railroad in both local and more general terms, but also guide us in attaining some knowledge of its continued importance within the framework of cultural representation.  I found an ideal informant in Dr. Veronica Watson, who has provided crucial information and research advice throughout the duration of this project.  Without her help, many aspects of this work would seem incomplete.

Interview with Dr. Veronica Watson
By: Carrie Aitkins

Veronica Watson is director of the Frederick Douglass Institute for Intercultural Research and a professor in the Department of English at Indiana University of Pennsylvania.  Her academic interests include: the Literature of White Estrangement; African American literature and culture; Critical Whiteness Studies; Twentieth Century American Fiction; and Slave Narratives.  She was also instrumental in co-organizing with Dr. Chris Catalfamo a University Museum exhibit on the Underground Railroad in Indiana County called Freedom in the Air, the exhibition catalogue of which is available to view on this website.

  CA:  In your opinion, what is the continued significance of the Underground Railroad History in Indiana? 
  VW: It's part of this region's history, but few know of it.  It's a legacy of people pursuing social and racial justice, willing to sacrifice their mental, emotional and physical well-being, if necessary, for the liberation of those who made it to this county.  It's a history of black self-determination and interracial support and cooperation.  I cannot help but imagine that if more people in Indiana County knew and embraced this history, more might be willing to see continuing challenges to equity and justice that exist in our community now. 


   CA:  Within the history of the Underground Railroad (not just in Indiana), do you think that it is possible to better document the essential role which African Americans had in the creation of this movement (which is essentially a resistance movement-- especially in contrast to how much is known about the role of the abolitionists? 

   VW: First, let me affirm that that's work that needs to be done.  The story of the Abolitionist Movement is still largely told as a story of white courage, benevolence and agency.  The truth is, however, that the large numbers of black Americans who sought their own freedom--through escape, revolution, and in-place modes of resistance--made the institution of slavery a contested issue in this country.  It was our agency and willingness to challenge the system that made slavery a moral, ethical, social and political crisis in this country.  So that work absolutely needs to be done.  White Americans came later to the party, but those of the stories that we know, when we know the stories at all.  But to the question of is it possible to document the essential role of African Americans, I'd have to say much of the groundwork has already been laid.  We have the narratives; know many of the names--both of individuals as well as institutions--in 18th and 19th century black America that were critical in sustaining the UGRR.  The bigger problem is not in documenting the role, but in making that role central to the history we teach, the figures we celebrate, and the construction of the narrative of freedom in this country.      

  CA:  Concerning the driving and guided tours of the Underground Railroad in Indiana, have you or anyone you know participated in these tours?  Do you think that more could be done to educate both IUP students and local residents in regards to its history? 

  VW: No, I've never participated in a driving or guided UGRR tour.  Yes, more could be done, especially at the elementary and middle school levels.  But it's needed even at the high school level so that we're not getting students in college who really think that African Americans were freed because white Americans were good enough to fight for their freedom.             

Source Cited

            Watson, Dr. Veronica.  E-mail Interview.  31 Oct. 2013.
For more information about our informant, please visit her IUP webpage at:

No comments:

Post a Comment